Make it Mandy Catering, LLC offers a variety of savory and sweet, while not sacrificing taste. Make it Mandy also has a passion to cater to those with dietary restrictions. These include many menu items that can be made gluten free, soy free, dairy free, nut free, plant based and vegan friendly. Click here to see the menu.
Call to place your order
“Thank you for being my go to caterer for any special occasion. You did a wonderful job on my daughter's 1st birthday cake. Your sweet potato pies were simply delicious. Your vegetarian meatballs for our New Year's Eve church dinner still bring compliments. I can't wait for my next function just so I can order Amanda's dishes and baked goods. "
R. Callion
Youngstown, OH
The items below are always available and hand made with the freshest ingredients. Browse the menu, make your selections and contact Make it Mandy to place your order today! (V=vegetarian, Vg=vegan, DF=dairy free, GF=gluten free, SF=soy free). These options are available for some dishes at an additional charge).
A baked dish with a combination of different cheeses and spices. (DF and GF options available)
Serving Size
Full Size (9x13)
$48Savory and satisfying mouth watering patties that even the carnivore in you will enjoy!
12 patties
$42
A handcrafted vegetarian dish served in a sweet and tangy sauce that promises to leave you wanting more! (GF,DF and SF option available)
1 dz
$28
New Option
New choice
Slow cooked chicken wings served in your choice of bbq, spicy chipotle or teryaki sauce.
1 dz
$32
Perfectly seasoned turkey paired with a medley of beans, vegetables and just the right amount of spice. (V/Vg option available)
Servings
Full (9x13)
$35Cornbread Muffins (1 dz)
$22Thinly sliced sweet potatoes, seasoned and baked.
9x13
$32
Mandy's version of a Jamaican patty. Seasoned meat filling enclosed in a flaky crust. (V, VG, DF option available)
1dz
$42.99
The items below are always available and hand made with the freshest ingredients. Browse the menu, make your selections and contact Make it Mandy to place your order today! (V, Vg, DF, and GF options available for select items)
Decadent chocolate with a glazed icing sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Full size (8x8)
$28
Rich and flavorful handcrafted pudding layered with banana and wafers
Choose between vanilla, chocolate or red velvet flavors. Order by the dz of same flavor. (Vegan, DF, GF options available for additional cost. Specialty cupcakes and decorations are an extra charge)
1 dz
$36
Refreshing lemon cookies with just the right amount of tart and sweet.
1 Dz
$22
Baked apples and spices with a crumb topping
Servings
Full (9x13)
$35Cake on a stick. Choose between vanilla, chocolate or red velvet flavors and your choice of vanilla or chocolate icing. (Order by the dozen-same flavor). Additional flavors may be available upon request for an additional fee.
1dz
$40